Skip to content
Rotate at 50 logoROTATE @50
All posts

Weather · · Patrick Saxton

Your First Real Weather Decisions as a New Pilot

As a student, your instructor makes the go/no-go call. Once you're certificated, it's all yours. Here's how to think through weather when the clouds aren't cooperating.

As a student pilot, there’s always someone else in the decision loop. Your instructor checks the weather, signs your solo endorsement, and might cancel the flight if it doesn’t look right.

After the checkride, that’s gone. The weather decision is yours.

Bill Williams wrote about some of his first decisions as a newly certificated pilot. On one flight to Prescott, Arizona, he woke up to clouds as low as 1,500 feet in a place that usually has 100 miles of visibility. On another, his first trip with his wife into the Arizona high country for a weekend with friends, he said being pilot in command was teaching him a lot, and there were weather decisions to make.

That’s the transition every new pilot goes through. Here’s how I’d think about it.

Start with personal minimums

Before you’re ever in the moment, decide your limits. Write them down.

  • Lowest ceiling you’ll depart under.
  • Lowest visibility.
  • Maximum wind and crosswind.
  • Day versus night limits, which should usually be more conservative.

These should be higher than the legal minimums, especially as a new pilot. Revisit them as you gain experience.

The point is to make the decision before you’re standing on the ramp with a passenger who’s excited to go.

Think about the whole flight

It’s not just the weather at departure. Ask:

  • What’s it doing now, and what’s the trend? Getting better or worse?
  • What’s en route? Terrain, clouds, visibility.
  • What’s at the destination when I arrive?
  • What’s it doing when I want to come home?

Keep your outs

On the Prescott flight, Bill described dodging clouds over Phoenix in poor visibility. His passenger asked if he was worried. He thought about it and realized he wasn’t, because he had a lot of outs.

That’s the key idea. A flight is safer when you have options. Airports to land at along the way. Room to turn around. Fuel to divert. Good weather behind you.

The danger is when those outs disappear one at a time without you noticing. Clouds close in behind you. Fuel gets tighter. The last good airport slips behind.

Ask yourself regularly: if this gets worse, what do I do? If you don’t have an answer, that’s your answer.

Watch for pressure

Some pressures that push pilots into bad weather:

  • Passengers. You don’t want to disappoint them. Your first trip with family is a classic case.
  • Plans. A reservation, an event, people waiting.
  • Getting home. Sunday-afternoon “get-home-itis” is a real thing.
  • Sunk cost. You’ve already driven to the airport, preflighted and loaded the bags.

Name the pressure when you feel it. Just saying it out loud helps. Then make the decision as if none of it existed.

Brief your passengers before you go: “We might not go, or we might turn around. If we do, it’s the right call.” That takes a lot of pressure off you later.

Use the tools, but look outside

Get a full briefing. Read METARs, TAFs, area forecasts, radar, satellite and pilot reports. Use flight following so ATC can help.

But also look at the sky. If it looks worse than the forecast, believe your eyes.

Your Minimums. Your Decision.

Here’s what I’d tell every new pilot: you’ll never regret a flight you didn’t take for weather. You might regret one you did.

Bill’s flights worked out because he had options and kept them. That’s the habit to build. And if you decide to stay on the ground, drive, wait a day or turn around, that’s not a failure.

That’s the kind of thing we work through on Rotate at 50. Subscribe on YouTube and come fly along.

That’s exactly what a good pilot does.

More on weather