Flight Training · · Patrick Saxton
Why Flying With a Different Instructor Now and Then Helps
Every instructor teaches a little differently. A lesson with someone new can expose habits you didn't know you had and fill gaps you didn't know were there.
One of the Student Pilot Cast episodes is called “The Anonymous CFI.” Bill Williams flew one lesson with an instructor he never flew with again, and he never got permission to publish that instructor’s voice, so the cockpit audio was cut and the name stayed private.
What stuck with me was his comment about the flight. He said he liked flying with different instructors because it kept him on his toes, and because everyone has a different style, he always learned something.
I think that’s right. And it’s worth talking about, because a lot of students feel loyal to their instructor in a way that makes them avoid ever flying with anybody else.
Why your regular instructor matters
Let’s be clear first. Consistency with one main instructor is a good thing.
Your instructor knows where you are in the syllabus. They know which maneuvers you’ve nailed and which still need work. They know your habits. You don’t spend the first twenty minutes of every lesson getting acquainted.
So this isn’t about hopping between instructors every week. It’s about the occasional lesson with someone new.
What a different instructor gives you
Fresh eyes. After twenty hours with you, your instructor has seen your landings so many times that small habits stop standing out. Someone new might notice right away that you float every landing because you carry five extra knots on final.
A different explanation. Sometimes a concept doesn’t click the way your instructor explains it. A different instructor describes the same thing in different words, and suddenly it makes sense.
Less comfort. This one’s subtle. When you fly with the same person all the time, you start to rely on their cues. A raised eyebrow. A hand drifting toward the throttle. A new instructor doesn’t give you those cues, so you find out whether you really know it.
Checkride practice. Your examiner will be a stranger. The more you’ve flown with people who aren’t your regular instructor, the less that feels like a big deal.
When it happens naturally
Sometimes you don’t choose it. Your instructor gets sick, goes on vacation or leaves for an airline job. Bill’s prep for his Stage III check ended up being with a different instructor than he planned. He called that episode “Hijacked.”
That can feel disruptive. Try to treat it as an opportunity instead.
How to make a lesson with someone new count
Brief them. Tell them where you are, what you’ve been working on and what’s giving you trouble. Bring your logbook and training record.
Ask what they’d focus on. Then listen. You might get a perspective your regular instructor hasn’t offered.
Don’t argue technique in the air. If they teach something differently from your regular instructor, fly it their way for the lesson, then talk it through on the ground. Afterward, mention it to your main instructor.
Take notes. What did they notice? What did they say that made something click?
A note on the maneuvers
On Bill’s anonymous CFI flight, he worked on short- and soft-field landings, steep turns, hood work, minimum controllable airspeed and power-on and power-off stalls. That’s a pretty full checkride-prep list. A lesson like that, with someone who hasn’t seen you fly before, is about as good a mock checkride as you can get.
One Main Instructor. More Than One Perspective.
Stick with a primary instructor for consistency. But once in a while, fly with someone else on purpose.
You’ll either confirm you’re doing well, or you’ll find a gap before an examiner does. Both outcomes are good.
We keep working through topics like this on Rotate at 50. Subscribe on YouTube if you want to follow along.
Consistency with your primary instructor matters. So does an occasional lesson with someone who sees your flying fresh.