Landings · · Patrick Saxton
Shorts and Softs: Short-Field and Soft-Field Takeoffs and Landings
Two sets of performance takeoffs and landings that show up on every private pilot checkride, and in real life the first time you fly into a grass strip.
Bill Williams called them “shorts and softs.” Within four days, he had three dual lessons on them, and he kept practicing them solo right up to his checkride. In one episode he noted that he’d made a strategic mistake in how he scheduled this part of his training, and told listeners to learn from it.
His point stands: these maneuvers take repetition, and they’re easy to underestimate.
So what are they?
Short-field: when the runway is the limit
A short-field takeoff or landing is for a runway that’s short, or has an obstacle at the end, like trees or power lines.
Short-field takeoff. Use every foot. Line up at the very beginning of the runway. Flaps as the handbook recommends. Hold the brakes, add full power, then release. Rotate at the recommended speed and climb at Vx, the best angle of climb speed, until you’re clear of the obstacle. Then lower the nose to Vy and clean up.
Short-field landing. It’s about precision. Fly a stabilized approach at the recommended approach speed, usually with full flaps. Pick a touchdown point and land on it, or within the standard on your checkride. For the private ACS, that means touching down at or within 200 feet beyond your point. After touchdown, retract flaps if the handbook says to, and brake firmly.
The secret to a good short-field landing is the approach. If your speed is too fast, you float past your point. If it’s sloppy, you can’t land on a specific spot. Get the airspeed right early.
Soft-field: when the surface is the problem
Soft-field techniques are for grass, sand, mud or snow. Anywhere the wheels might dig in.
Soft-field takeoff. Keep moving. Don’t stop on the soft surface if you can avoid it. Hold the yoke back to keep weight off the nose wheel while you taxi and as you add power. As the airplane accelerates, it lifts off at a low speed in ground effect. Then lower the nose slightly and stay in ground effect while you accelerate to Vx or Vy before climbing.
That ground effect part is important. The airplane can fly in ground effect at a speed it couldn’t climb at. Try to climb out too early and it can settle back down.
Soft-field landing. Touch down as gently and slowly as possible, with the nose high. Keep back pressure after touchdown to hold the nose wheel off the ground as long as you can. Add a touch of power if needed to soften the landing. Keep the yoke back as you taxi.
Practicing them well
Use the handbook. Speeds and flap settings vary by airplane. Know yours before you go.
Practice on purpose. Tell yourself before each pattern which one you’re doing. Short-field on this one. Soft-field on the next.
Watch for FOD. Bill had a session where he dealt with foreign object debris on the runway and a go-around on a busy day. Busy airports and unfamiliar surfaces add variables. Keep your eyes open.
Go around early. On a short-field approach, if you’re not stabilized, don’t try to save it. Go around and set it up again.
Fly them solo. Once your instructor signs you off, practicing alone builds real confidence.
Why they matter later
Pass the checkride, and these techniques don’t go away. The first time you fly into a pretty grass strip for a fly-in breakfast, the soft-field technique is exactly what you’ll want. The first time you fly into a short runway with trees at the end, short-field is the plan.
Learn them well now. They’re not just checkride tasks.
Short. Soft. Precise.
These are the landings that take you to grass strips, short runways and fly-in breakfasts. They deserve real practice.
If you want to see this in the airplane, subscribe to Rotate at 50 on YouTube and fly along.
Get the approach right and the short-field landing usually takes care of itself.